Insurance made easy with people who care, based here in Kentucky.

A black and white drawing of a house on a white background.

Personal
Insurance

Home, auto, & more.
A black and white drawing of a store with a person 's face in the window.

Business
Insurance

Coverage for growth.
A black and white drawing of a barn and a field.

Farm

Insurance

Secure your land.

Protect what matters with insurance built for you.

At Schumacher Insurance, we know that insurance isn’t just about policies—it’s about people. That’s why we provide personalized coverage for families, businesses, and farms throughout Maysville, KY, and beyond. Our locally owned and operated agency makes insurance simple, ensuring you get protection that truly fits your needs.
A black and white drawing of a couple holding a child.

Personal Insurance

From home and auto to life and renter’s insurance, we provide coverage that fits your lifestyle. Our team works with you to find the right policies, ensuring peace of mind for every stage of life.
Learn more
A black and white drawing of a building with a person standing in front of it.

Business Insurance

Safeguard your company with custom business insurance solutions. From general liability to commercial auto and property coverage, we help businesses in Maysville, KY, and beyond stay protected and prepared for anything.
Learn more

Why choose Schumacher Insurance Agency?

01

Locally
Owned

We’re more than an agency—we’re your neighbors. Our team builds long-term relationships with clients, offering expert guidance and friendly, personalized service every step of the way.

02

Custom

Coverage

No two clients are the same. That’s why we take the time to understand your needs and find the right insurance solutions that fit your life, business, or farm.

03

Trusted

Support

Questions about coverage? Claims concerns? We’re always here. Our experienced agents make insurance easy, offering responsive support and clear answers whenever you need them.

Request a Free Quote

Contact Us

Client Testimonials

Jake O'Mara has been a HUGE help to me these past few months with some bad vehicular luck. I would highly recommend Schumacher Insurance over anyone else in town.

Sam C.

Schumacher insurance is the best there is. The personal care I get for both my business and personal coverage is next level. Eric and his team always go above and beyond. I am so thankful for all they do.

David G.

Owner went above and beyond when we had a car totaled. The insurance company was playing games and tried to pull our rental out from under us, and then delayed payback to the point we almost missed a sale on our replacement car. One call to the local folks resolved the issue in both cases. They may not be the cheapest in town, but local folks matter, and the service was great.

Daniel G.

Friendly and knowledgeable staff that made changing my coverage a painless transition.

Charlie S.

Get coverage that works for you.

Whether you need home, auto, business, or farm insurance, we’re here to help. At Schumacher Insurance, we make finding the right coverage simple and stress-free. Our trusted agents will walk you through your options so you can get the protection you deserve. Request a quote today.